I had heard a few times that the shows presented at the “night before Winterail” pizza party were usually really good, and sometimes better than the shows at Winterail itself. This year the party was sponsored by Railfan & Railroad magazine. After some initial hesitation I decided to attend and also present at this event. Here’s what I thought:
Shows: The quality of the shows ranged from very good to very ungood. From what I could tell, the lineup was first-come, first-served, so there was no screening of content or quality of the shows beforehand. Format was a mixture of digital shows (using ProShow) along with some traditional slide presentations. Shows which stand out in my mind were Ken Storey’s “Great Railfan Trip 2005″ which presented a selection of excellent photos from the western United States of both freight action and the UP 3985, along with Ken Harrison’s show featuring railroad operations in Brazil. Steve Barry presented “Steve’s Steamy Shorts” which were fun to watch. Nate Muhlethaler narrated a show featuring Mexican railroads which was informative as well as having a good variety of photos. Robert Scott presented his show featuring North Dakota railroading which I had previously seen. Barry Christensen presented “Gateways to the South” which darn near bored me to death, with average-quality images of modern freight trains in the southeastern US. Nose-coupled Dash 9 roster shots just don’t excite me. Overall the show quality was about what I expected, some good ones and some bad ones.
Facilities: The theater worked fine for the crowd of 100-150 people, and didn’t have the ventilation issues that would be seen the next day at the main Winterail show.
Show Organization: I’ve got two things to say about the show organization, neither one of them good. The timekeeping was very poor. 20% of the presenters weren’t able to show anything because some other presenters shows went longer than their allotted slots and took up too much time. The folks running the show allowed a couple of the live-narrated slideshows to go on for longer than the 15 minute limit which had been stated. Given that a few of the digital shows (such as mine, at 7 minutes) were far shorter than 15 minutes, the fact that they ran out of time shows serious time-management problems.
Perhaps my bigger frustration was the lack of planning or organization for the projection of digital shows. I don’t know to what extent the Winterail and Railfan & Railroad folks cooperated for the sharing of equipment and such, so these are merely observations from a presenter. When I got there, I was told to give my show (on CD) to Alex Ramos, who took it but admitted he didn’t know exactly what he was doing. After several minutes he came back out of the building, apparently having been told that “the Winterail people” wouldn’t let him load the Friday presentations onto the Winterail computer. As such, he had no idea what computer was going to be used to show the digital shows. One of the guys I was with (another attendee) happened to have his laptop along, so his laptop ended up being used to present the digital shows. Once we got the shows rolling so to speak, it became obvious that the digital projector had some color issues… the color tones were off, as well as all of the images being noticeably darker than they should have been. Several of the photos in my presentation lost a lot of detail that just became black because of the darkening of the images.
Who hosts a digital slideshow without a computer to project the images? And why wasn’t the projector tested to ensure the colors were correct?
Food: For $7 I expected more than two slices of shitty Domino’s pizza. Evan Werkema was overheard exclaiming “That stuff is worse than Tombstone!” I understand that the profits went to rail preservation, but what a joke.
Overall: A few of the shows were interesting. The lack of show organization and time management left a sour taste in my mouth along with the sour taste of crappy, limited-quantity pizza. Would I go again? Doubtful.
Reflecting The Times:
Fast Trains:
Tracks in the Snow: