Adobe’s Photoshop Lightroom has been on sale for 9 months now and with the release of version 1.2 more folks are starting to ask about it and if it is the right tool. I’ve known for a while why Adobe Photoshop Lightroom works for me, but I haven’t taken the time to put my thoughts to words. My motivation for this post comes from a blog post by another photographer that I think does a good job of clarifying the purposes of CS and Lightroom.
George Barr is a fine art photographer and user of Photoshop (presumably a CS version). In a recent blog post George helped me with placing Lightroom into the spectrum of photo editing tools. George says:
When I went to inkjet printing of my black and white images, it seemed perfectly natural to take advantage of the powerful editing tools available via computer, in my case with Photoshop. I could now manipulate both further and more accurately and in smaller areas and more areas than ever before.
It was a natural extension to continue these techniques when I started working in colour and it didn’t even occur to me that I should have any loyalty to the original colour as recorded.
Gasp! No loyalty to the original color? For a railfan photographer that (for the most part) is a no no. He continues…
This is radically different from colour slide photographers (whatever the format) who have very strong ideas of maintaining colour fidelity and go to great lengths to do so. When these people switch to the digital darkroom, they tend to make global changes (as if they were filtering in the camera) and that’s about all. For people like this applications like Lightroom are all they need…
Those of us who have no loyalty to the original scene, thinking of it only in terms of fodder for our art work tend to prefer to use Photoshop and it’s powerful ways of manipulating an image.
Now we’re talking! Most railfans have a strong loyalty to the original color of the image and to the original scene, especially when their favorite paint scheme or location is depicted. Based on that thought the reality is we don’t all need Photoshop CS* for what we do, we need something that can globally edit the image to get the look just right quickly…and that Lightroom does well and that’s why I use it.
*While CS may not be required, Lightroom does not have output sharpening, so another tool is required to perform that work.
Reflecting The Times:
Fast Trains:
Tracks in the Snow: